The Battle of Eyeliners: Pencil, Liquid, and Gel - Pros and Cons Explored

July 31,2023

Eyeliner is a makeup essential that can transform your eyes and elevate your overall look. However, with a plethora of options available, choosing the right type of eyeliner can be overwhelming. In this blog post, we will delve into the pros and cons of three popular eyeliner types: pencil, liquid, and gel. By understanding their unique characteristics, you’ll be able to make an informed decision and achieve stunning eye makeup looks.



GZMT-13 (4)(2).jpg



Pencil Eyeliner:


Pencil eyeliners are a classic choice for many makeup enthusiasts. Here are the pros and cons:




Versatility: Pencil eyeliners offer versatility, allowing you to create both subtle and bold looks.
Ease of Use: They are beginner-friendly and provide better control during application.
Smudging Potential: Pencil eyeliners can be smudged for a smoky effect or blended with other eyeshadows.




Durability: Pencil eyeliners tend to smudge and fade more quickly, especially in humid conditions.
Precision: Achieving precise lines can be challenging due to the thicker and less precise tip.
Sharpening: Regular sharpening is required, leading to product wastage.




Liquid Eyeliner:


Liquid eyeliners are known for their precision and intense pigmentation. Let’s explore their pros and cons:




Precision: Liquid eyeliners come with fine, pointed applicators that allow for precise lines and intricate designs.
Longevity: Once dry, liquid eyeliners tend to be long-lasting and resistant to smudging.
Intensity: They offer intense color payoff, making your eyes pop and creating a dramatic effect.




Learning Curve: Liquid eyeliners require practice and a steady hand to achieve a flawless application.
Drying Time: They take longer to dry, which can lead to accidental smudging if not given enough time to set.
Limited Blending: Liquid eyeliners are not easily blendable, making it difficult to achieve a smoky effect.




Gel Eyeliner:


Gel eyeliners combine the best of both worlds, offering the precision of liquid liners and the ease of use of pencil liners. Let’s explore their pros and cons:




Precision and Control: Gel eyeliners are applied with a brush, allowing for precise lines and creative designs.
Longevity: Once set, gel eyeliners are smudge-proof and can last all day without fading.
Versatility: They can be used to create various looks, from thin lines to bold wings.




Brush Dependency: Gel eyeliners require a separate brush for application, which adds an extra step to the process.
Drying Time: Similar to liquid eyeliners, gel eyeliners need time to dry, so patience is required.
Portability: Carrying a brush and a pot of gel eyeliner may not be as convenient as a pencil or liquid liner.





Choosing the right eyeliner type depends on your personal preferences, skill level, and desired look. Pencil eyeliners offer versatility, liquid eyeliners provide precision, and gel eyeliners combine the best of both worlds. Consider the pros and cons discussed above to make an informed decision and achieve flawless eyeliner looks that enhance your eyes and overall makeup. Experiment with different types to find your favorite and unleash your creativity!